New York Strips, Pan Seared, With Cherry Tomatoes and Smashed Potatoes…

As the More is More Mom®, I’m all about……..more updated steak and potatoes!  There is something so appealing about a stick to your ribs dinner as the weather is getting colder. While a juicy grilled steak and good old fashioned mashed potatoes sound delicious, why not take it up a notch? I am totally on a roll with my Nick. Normally he is not much of a carnivore, he’s a pasta guy, but as he was clearing his plate he said, “This is the best steak ever!” High praise from someone whose idea of culinary excellence is fast food dining……..

Timing is everything. I prefer to have all of my ingredients prepped before I start cooking for a more streamlined process. For instance, I also served Smashed Potatoes (the recipe follows immediately), so I already boiled and smashed the potatoes prior to cooking the steaks. That way, when I was finished with the skillet I used for the steak, I could use it right away to finish off the potatoes. It couldn’t be simpler!

Pan Seared New York Strips Steaks with Cherry Tomatoes:

Serves 4

3 Tbsp oil

Fine ground sea salt for sprinkling

Cracked black pepper for sprinkling

4 – New York Strip Steaks

8 large garlic cloves, pressed

2 pints of cherry tomatoes, red and yellow

1 – ¾ oz package of basil leaves, chopped

Pre-heat oven to 375°

Heat 2 Tbsp of oil, over medium-high heat, in a large skillet

Season steaks with salt and pepper

Sear steaks in skillet, in batches if necessary, for approximately 5 minutes per side

Prepare a rimmed baking sheet, lining it with aluminum foil

After searing, place the steaks on the baking sheet and cook in oven for approximately 10 minutes (could be sooner, could be later. Insert an instant read thermometer into the center of the steak checking temperature; 120° for medium-rare).

 Remove and let stand on a platter for 15 minutes.

Cherry Tomatoes:

In a small skillet, heat 1 Tbsp oil in a small skillet



Sauté for no more than a minute


Cherry tomatoes

Sprinkle with coarse seal salt

Mix and cook for approximately 3-4 minutes



Stir until well mixed

Remove from heat and set aside

Smashed Potatoes:

2- 24 oz bags of small, red potatoes, scrubbed clean

Course sea salt for sprinkling

Cracked black pepper for sprinkling

Olive oil

1 cup grated cheese, such as a Parmigiano-Reggiano or Paremesan

In a large pot, place the potatoes and cover with cold water

Bring water to a boil and cook the potatoes for 15-20 minutes

You’ll want the potatoes cooked through, but not so mushy they fall apart

Drain and place in a single layer on a rimmed baking sheet (or two) lined with aluminum foil.

With a fork or potato masher, smash the potatoes so they are fairly flat, but not so much that they are smooshed and fall apart.

Sprinkle with course sea salt and cracked black pepper.

Set aside until ready to finish in the skillet. Of course these can be made on their own, but I made them in the left over juices from the steak for a little extra flavor.


2- Tbsp oil to pan, heating through

Add the smashed potatoes, transferring them to the pan one at a time, until the pan is full. You may need to work in batches.

Cook until they are golden brown and flip them over one at a time

Sprinkle with a little more salt and pepper

Sprinkle with cheese for those that like it

Cook until the cheese is melted and they are golden brown

My family loves broccoli, scrub brush of the intestines, so we eat a lot of it. Boiled until blanched and then slathered in butter (at least we don’t also add cheese).


On a dinner plate, place a few smashed potatoes, broccoli a serving of steak covered in cherry tomatoes and serve!

More family dinners, more tasty tomatoes, more smashed potatoes, more best steak ever!!

New York Strips Steaks, Pan Seared With Cherry Tomatoes and Smashed Potatoes


Filed under Family Life, More is More Mom, Recipes

2 responses to “New York Strips, Pan Seared, With Cherry Tomatoes and Smashed Potatoes…

  1. Yum! Will make when my son comes home from college. New York strip is his favorite, and at the neighborhood restaurant they cost @ $30 each!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s